COBALT CHROMIUM DEBRIS RELEASE IN CONTEMPORARY TOTAL KNEE ARTHROPLASTY MAY BE AN UNDER-RECOGNIZED CLINICAL ISSUE

Abstract

AbstractIntroductionSeveral studies have reported significant cobalt(Co) and chromium(Cr) elevations in the blood of patients with total-knee-replacements (TKRs), and histological signs of metal sensitivity have been reported in up to 44% of patients undergoing revision of their TKRs. We carried out this investigation to determine the source and quantity of metal release in TKRs.MethodologyWe identified all TKRs with polished CoCr trays (N=59) [Vanguard=29, Attune=4 and PFC=26]. These were analysed using peer-reviewed [coordinate-measuring-machine (CMM)] methodology to measure the volumetric wear of the polyethylene (PE) bearing surfaces and trays. The trays were analysed using 2D-profilometry (surface roughness-Ra) and 4D-microscopy. Histological and blood metal ion concentration analyses were performed.ResultsThe median(IQR) PE wear rate was 10(6to20) mm3/year. Microscopic analysis identified pitting on superior surface of 36(49%) trays. Ra [median (IQR)] of superior surface of pitted trays [0.076 (0.060–0.084) µm] showed a statistically significant increase (p<0.001) compared with unpitted trays [0.057(0.049–0.066) µm]. 4D-microscopy and CMM analysis estimated wear volumes of up to 2mm3 secondary to pitting. The median (range) Co and Cr concentrations were 2.5µg/l (0.2–69.4) and 1.7µg/l (0.5–12.5) respectively in 40 patients. Of the tissue samples examined in 30 patients,6 had at-least “mild”-ALVAL infiltrate. All corresponding “ALVAL” explants were found to be pitted and/or show evidence of loosening of the tray.ConclusionThis study provides further evidence that CoCr release in TKR appears to be an under-recognised cause of adverse clinical outcomes. Gross metal ion elevations occurred in association with micromotion/loosening of the tray.