Coastal insect herbivore communities are affected more by local environmental conditions than by plant genotype

Abstract

Abstract. 1 We compared the effects of plant genotype and local environment on population densities of a community of coastal insect herbivores in west-central Florida. Reciprocal transplants of four genotypes of three species of coastal plants, Borrichia frutescens, Iva frutescens and Limbricata, were made in July 1992 between a series of off-shore islands. 2 For each plant species, phytophagous insects with a wide range of feeding modes including gall-makers, stem borers, leaf miners and sap suckers were affected more by local environment than by plant genotype. Whereas host genotype had a significant effect on the population densities of gall-makers on B.frutescens in the spring of 1993, no significant effect on the denrities of any other insect species was found and the effect on the gall-makers on Borrichia disappeared in the summer, 1 year after the transplants had been made. In our study, local environment had by far the greatest effect on insect population densities among islands. This is an unusual result because in other studies over 80% of the insect species examined have been affected by plant genotype (Karban, 1992). This result is consistent with that reported by Stiling (1994), who censused populations of two phytophagous insects on reciprocal transplantr ot Borrichia in north Florida. 3 Local environment also had an effect on insect population densities within islands. This result contrasts with similar studies performed in north Florida (Stiling, 1994), where population densities did not differ within areas, and underlies how some biotic processes may change with in the same community even over relatively small changes in species range.