Clinical outcome is significantly better with spheroid-based autologous chondrocyte implantation manufactured with more stringent cell culture criteria

Abstract

Spherox (CO.DON AG) is an autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) product, consisting of spheroids of human autologous matrix-associated chondrocytes. The tendency of primary chondrocytes to dedifferentiate during cultivation and the high biologic variability caused by the autologous nature of the starting material makes it challenging to design a manufacturing process that performs consistently and delivers products that meet their intended function and the high quality criteria for cell-based ATMPs. The current study was submitted during the European authorization procedure, and addresses the requirement to justify the operational ranges of the manufacturing process using clinical data. In order to define the operational ranges, statistical correlation analyses were conducted between process parameters and clinical improvement data of 120 patients from Phase II and III treated with ACI (KOOS score, 1 year follow-up). This approach identified cell culture time as a critical process parameter that negatively correlates with the product's efficacy. Subsequent analyses of the Phase III patients that were treated with chondrocyte spheroids that have been manufactured with shorter monolayer and spheroid cultivation times showed a higher average clinical improvement as well as a higher responder rate compared to the total group. In addition, retrospective analyses demonstrated superiority for the treatment with short-cultivated chondrocyte spheroids over micro-fracture treatment. These findings underscore the need to use clinical data to optimize the manufacturing process for autologous cell-based therapies. We expect that restricting the cultivation times during manufacturing minimizes the production of suboptimal batches, thus ensuring an efficacious product.