Abstract

This is a study of 109 patients who attended the Research Clinic for Holistic Medicine in Copenhagen during the 2004–2006 period, grouped according to the symptoms they presented with. Every new patient was asked to answer a 10-question composite questionnaire containing QOL1, QOL5, and four questions on ability to function socially, ability to function sexually, ability to love, and ability to work, rated on a 5-point Likert scale, on initial contact and after 1–3 months, when the patient had received about five treatments, the patient was asked to complete the questionnaire again, and finally again after 1 year. All had been to their general practitioner first with their problems and 30% had been in psychological/psychiatric treatment before. The patients were treated with short-time psychodynamic therapy (less than 40 sessions) including bodywork when necessary. More than half the patients had a bad or very bad self-assessed mental health before treatment, but after treatment only 15% reported a bad or very bad mental health (p < 0.001). Most had a complex of mental, somatic, existential, and sexual problems. Of the patients, 69.72% did the retest after treatment. We conclude that clinical holistic medicine was able to help the majority of these patients, even when patients had not been sufficiently helped by drugs, psychiatry, or psychology before. We found that outcome of therapy was not connected with severity of initial condition, but probably with the former experience of treatment. If psychiatric or psychological treatment had already failed, the patients were more difficult to help. The Square Curve Paradigm was used to document a large, immediate and lasting effect of the therapy.

Highlights

  • A number of studies have documented the efficiency of psychodynamic short-time therapy[1,2,3], but the problem has been that the immediate clinical efficiency has been modest compared to the effect of drugs, especially with severe mental problems and diseases

  • In spite of all this activity, the effect of holistic medicine in general is still not clear. This is primarily because the term refers to hundreds of treatment systems focused on “the whole patient” and not primarily on the symptoms or the disease as it is in normal practice in today’s mainstream biomedicine, pharmacological medicine. It seems that what works in holistic medicine is basically that the physician or therapist induces healing on an existential level, called salutogenesis by Aaron Antonovsky (1923–1994)[6,7], by creating a deep shift in the consciousness of the patient towards the more positive and constructive

  • The present study aims to explore the effectiveness of clinical holistic medicine on a variety of patients that have not been sufficiently helped by their biomedically oriented general practitioner, or felt insufficiently helped by their psychiatrist and/or other health professionals in the biomedically oriented public health system of Denmark

Read more

Summary

Introduction

A number of studies have documented the efficiency of psychodynamic short-time therapy[1,2,3], but the problem has been that the immediate clinical efficiency has been modest compared to the effect of drugs, especially with severe mental problems and diseases. In spite of all this activity, the effect of holistic medicine in general is still not clear This is primarily because the term refers to hundreds of treatment systems focused on “the whole patient” and not primarily on the symptoms or the disease as it is in normal practice in today’s mainstream biomedicine, pharmacological medicine. It seems that what works in holistic medicine is basically that the physician or therapist induces healing on an existential level, called salutogenesis by Aaron Antonovsky (1923–1994)[6,7], by creating a deep shift in the consciousness of the patient towards the more positive and constructive

Objectives
Methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call