Climate change or just new software? The impact of Extrap software on ADCP discharge measurements in Norway

Abstract

<p>Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers (ADCP) are used a lot all around the world to measure discharge in rivers. These instruments measure most of the vertical velocity profile in rivers, but due to technical and physical limitations they cannot measure all the way to the surface or all the way to the bottom. To calculate discharge, the instruments (or software) need to extrapolate data into the un-measured regions. Previously there was no good and available tools to aid the operators in selecting proper extrapolation. In 2010 USGS released the software Extrap, which plots relative velocity versus relative depth for ADCP measurements, and this tool made it way easier to determine the correct extrapolation of data. (Extrap is now a part of Qrev/QrevInt). Before the introduction of Extrap, 80-90% of the ADCP-measurements at NVE used the default power law extrapolation in the ADCP’s standard software (WinRiver at the time), and around 5% used constant at top and no-slip at the bottom. The first if these assumes a velocity profile that is very similar to the logarithmic velocity profile that comes from classical boundary layer theory. The latter one is much steeper (constant) close to the surface.</p><p>After starting to use Extrap regularly, 60% of the measurements use the constant/no-slip extrapolation, while 40 % uses the power law extrapolation. This impacts the reported discharge from the measurements by reducing the reported discharge by on average 4% for the measurements using constant/no-slip extrapolation, and data users must be aware, because these measurements eventually form the foundation for the long time, continuous data series for discharge in our archives.</p><p>How will a climate researcher react to a 4% decrease in annual run-off from Norway?</p>