Cine clips increase the detection of thyroid pyramidal lobe in routine thyroid sonogram

Abstract

Background: Identification and resection of the thyroid pyramidal lobe is important for thyroid cancer surgery in order to prevent interval cancer in residual thyroid tissue. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine how often a thyroid pyramidal lobe is found in patients with and without previous thyroidectomy and to optimise the protocol for identifying thyroid pyramidal lobes during routine thyroid ultrasonography. Material and Methods: In this prospective study, a total of 1579 patients who received routine thyroid ultrasound scans at a single centre were enrolled. A dedicated standard scanning protocol was established containing both static images of the anterior neck superior to the thyroid as well as a transverse cine loop starting from the isthmus to the hyoid bone. The presence and features of thyroid pyramidal lobes were evaluated and compared. Results: Detection rate of thyroid pyramidal lobes in patients without thyroidectomy improved from 39.5% (480/1215) to 49.7% (640/1215) with protocol adding cine-loop as compared to protocol without cine-loop. The cine-loops were particularly helpful in the detection of thyroid pyramidal lobes when it is separated from the main lobe or in thyroidectomy patients. By adding assessment with cine-loop into the dedicated protocol, we have further detected different pathologies occurring on thyroid pyramidal lobes including benign and malignant solid nodules and pseudo-nodules of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis. Conclusion: The addition of dynamic assessment with cine-loop increases the detection rate of thyroid pyramidal lobes. By paying attention to the thyroid pyramidal lobe in pre-operative diagnostic sonographic images, we can help to avoid incomplete removal of the thyroid gland during thyroidectomy.