Cholangiography during laparoscopic cholecystectomy—cumulative sum analysis of an institutional learning curve

Abstract

The ability to perform intraoperative cholangiography during laparoscopic cholecystectomy is an essential skill for the laparoscopic biliary surgeon. The volume of experience required to be able to consistently obtain a cholangiogram during laparoscopic cholecystectomy has not been determined. Cumulative sum analysis is a statistical technique which generates a graphical display that identifies periods of performance that fall below a predetermined standard for a given task. The cumulative sum (S n) for a series of observations is defined as: ▪, where X i = 0 for a success, X i = 1 for a failure, and X o is the acceptable failure rate for the process under study. This function is plotted against the number of observations to create a curve. When the curve has a positive slope, the acceptable failure rate is being exceeded. When it reaches a plateau, the observed failure rate is equal to the acceptable failure rate. When the curve has a negative slope, the observed failure rate is lower than the acceptable failure rate. We performed a cumulative sum analysis of the first 97 intraoperative cholangiograms attempted during laparoscopic cholecystectomy at our institution. The results demonstrated that 46 cases were required to reach a level of proficiency where a cholangiogram could be obtained in 95% of attempts. Success rates of 85% and 90% were achieved at 16 and 25 cases, respectively. This form of analysis is a useful tool for estimating the number of attempts required to achieve a desired success rate when learning new procedures.