Childbirth experiences among women with fear of birth randomized to internet-based cognitive therapy or midwife counseling

Ingegerd Hildingsson,Christine Rubertsson

doi:10.1080/0167482x.2019.1634047

Ingegerd Hildingsson, Christine Rubertsson

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.1080/0167482x.2019.1634047

Copy DOI

Abstract

Background: Although women with fear of birth often report negative birth experiences, few studies have focused on their experiences in the long term. The aim of this study was to compare birth experiences a year after childbirth in two groups of women receiving treatment for experiencing fear of birth during pregnancy.Methods: As part of the U-CARE: Pregnancy Trial, a prospective multicenter randomized controlled trial comparing the effects of internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy (iCBT) and standard care among pregnant women with fear of birth. Women were recruited at three Swedish hospitals following a screening procedure that assessed their fear of birth. Data were collected online with the Childbirth Experience Questionnaire (CEQ), one question about the overall birth experience, and questions about personal background, collected before randomization.Results: A total of 181 women responded to the follow-up questionnaire a year after childbirth. Approximately half of participants reported a less positive birth experience. Preferred mode of birth, actual mode of birth, marital status and psychiatric history were associated with the domains of the CEQ. However, no statistically significant differences emerged between the treatment groups.Conclusions: Being randomized to receive iCBT or counseling with midwives for fear of birth was not associated with perceptions of the birth experience assessed a year after birth. Most participants reported less-than-positive birth experiences and scored low on the domain of the CEQ reflecting Own capacity. In response, additional research remains necessary to identify the best model of care that might facilitate positive experiences with giving birth among women with fear of birth.

Highlights

Women’s perceptions of their experiences with giving birth result from a complex process and pose long-term effects for women’s and their children’s health [1,2,3] and are related to a multitude of factors
The study was a secondary analysis of the U-CARE: Pregnancy Trial, a prospective randomized controlled trial comparing internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy (iCBT) with standard care among pregnant women with fear of birth, in which the primary outcome is self-assessed fear of birth
This study focuses of 181 of the randomized controlled trial (RCT) participants who completed the follow-up questionnaire a year after birth

Summary

Introduction

Women’s perceptions of their experiences with giving birth result from a complex process and pose long-term effects for women’s and their children’s health [1,2,3] and are related to a multitude of factors. Women with fear of birth often report negative birth experiences, few studies have focused on their experiences in the long term. The aim of this study was to compare birth experiences a year after childbirth in two groups of women receiving treatment for experiencing fear of birth during pregnancy. Conclusions: Being randomized to receive iCBT or counseling with midwives for fear of birth was not associated with perceptions of the birth experience assessed a year after birth. Most participants reported less-than-positive birth experiences and scored low on the domain of the CEQ reflecting Own capacity. Additional research remains necessary to identify the best model of care that might facilitate positive experiences with giving birth among women with fear of birth

Objectives

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion