Chemical reactivity parameters (HSAB) applied to magma evolution and ore formation

Abstract

Magmas are commonly described through the usual content of 10 major oxides. This requires a complex dimensional plot. Concepts of hard–soft acid–base (HSAB) interactions allow estimating chemical reactivity of elements, such as electronegativity, i.e. the chemical potential changed of sign, hardness and electrophilicity. For complex system, those values result from equalization methods, i.e. the equalization of the respective chemical potentials, or from ab-initio computations through density functional theory (DFT). They help to characterize silicate magmas by a single value describing their reactivity. Principles of minimum electrophilicity (mEP), maximum hardness (MHP) and minimum polarizability (mPP) indicate trends towards regions of higher stability. Those parameters are plotted within a fitness landscape diagram, highlighting toward which principle reactions trend. Major oxides, main minerals and magmas determine the respective fields in which evolve natural rocks. Three poles are identified, represented by silica and alkalis, whereas oxidation forms the third trend. Mantle-derived rocks show a large variation in electrophilicity compared to hardness. They present all characters of a closed chemical system, being simply described by the free Gibbs energy. Conversely, rocks contaminated within the continental crust show a large variation in hardness between a silica pole and an alkaline, defining two separate trends. The trends show the character of an open chemical system, requiring a Grand Potential description (i.e. taking into account the difference in chemical potential). The terms open and closed systems refer to thermodynamical description, implying contamination for the crust and recycling for the mantle. The specific role of alkalis contrasts with other cations, pointing to their behavior in modifying silicate polymer structures. A second application deals with the reactivity of the melt and its fluid phase. It leads to a better understanding on the mechanisms that control sequestration and transport of metals within the different phases during igneous activity. Based on high gas/melt partitioning for metals and similar reactivity, the gaseous phase is more attractive for metals than silicate melts. The presence of halogens in the fluid phase tends to reinforce hardness, making the fluid phase attractive for hard metals such as Sn or W. Conversely, the presence of S decreases hardness of the fluid phase that becomes attractive for soft metals such as Au, Ag and Cu.