Chemical Characterization of Inorganic Phosphorus Desorbed by Ion Exchange Membranes in Short‐ and Long‐Term Extraction Periods

Abstract

The chemical characterization of soil phosphorus (P) desorbed by anion and cation exchange membranes is of major importance to better understand which P forms are available to plants in short‐ and long‐term time periods. Two distinct soils, one acidic and one calcareous, were analyzed for P using two extraction procedures with mixed anion and cation exchange membranes. The short‐term (ST) experiment evaluated the effect of increasing the extraction periods up to 24 h, whereas the long‐term (LT) experiment consisted of a sequential extraction procedure using up to seven successive 24‐h extractions. In both experiments, the Chang and Jackson inorganic P fractionation methodology was carried out after each extraction treatment, and each treatment consisted of three replicates. Data were statistically analyzed by ANOVA and nonlinear regressions. In the ST experiment, increasing the extraction time increased the extracted P according to an asymptotic relationship (y=c−ab x ). Extracted P proceeded from the most labile fractions in the acidic soil. In calcareous soils, calcium phosphates may also contribute for extractable P. The LT experiment revealed that a single extraction, regardless of that extraction method, cannot predict the long‐term capacity of soils to supply P to the plants. An exponential relationship (P=a×n b ) was found between extracted P and the extraction number. Desorbed P proceeded from the most labile fractions in the acidic soil. However, in calcareous soils, some precaution is needed when considering the biological meaning of the results, because the occluded Fe phosphates also revealed significant decreases, probably due to the redox conditions in which these long extractions are performed.