Characters of multituberculates neglected in phylogenetic analyses of early mammals

Abstract

Multituberculate anatomy is compared with that of other mammals, with an emphasis on the characters that have either been neglected or misinterpreted in previous analyses of early mam mal relationships. These are: brain structure, backward masticatory power stroke (along with aspects of cranial design), and foot structure. New data on ear ossicles and a controversy con cerning multituberculate posture are also discussed. The following characters of multitubercu late skull and lower jaw are interpreted to be related to the backward masticatory power stroke: anterior orbital area roofed dorsally and without a floor (characteristic of advanced multituber culates), parietal postorbital process, lack of the angular process and a more anterior position of the coronoid process and masseteric fossa than in all other mammals. It is argued that the parallel development in the cranial structure of multituberculates and other mammals was lim ited by the backward masticatory power stroke of multituberculates that resulted in different configuration of the masticatory musculature and related osteology. In the postcranial skeleton the parallelism was limited by the structure of the multituberculate foot, in which the calca-neum contacts the fifth metatarsal (MtV) and the middle metatarsal (MtIII) is abducted 30° from the longitudinal axis of the tuber calcanei. Backward masticatory power stroke and related skull design do not show unequivocally whether multituberculates originated from some ‘tri-conodonts’ (a polyphyletic group), or independently from all other mammals from cynodonts. The foot structure refutes the origin of multituberculates from the Morganucodontidae. The brain structure allies the multituberculates with the Triconodontidae, the postcranial skeleton of which remains unknown. New data on ear ossicles suggest close relationships of multituber culates to all modern mammals. Lack of uncontested pre-Kimmeridgian multituberculates dis proves the separate origin of multituberculates from cynodonts.