Characterization of surfactant and phospholipid vesicles for use as pseudostationary phases in electrokinetic chromatography

Abstract

The physical, electrophoretic and chromatographic properties (mean diameter, electroosmotic flow, electrophoretic mobility, elution range, efficiency, retention, and hydrophobic, shape, and chemical selectivity) of three surfactant vesicles and one phospholipid vesicle were investigated and compared to a conventional micellar pseudostationary phase comprised of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). Chemical selectivity (solute-pseudostationary phase interactions) was discussed from the perspective of linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) analysis. Two of the surfactant vesicles were formulated from nonstoichiometric aqueous mixtures of oppositely charged, single-tailed surfactants, either cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) and sodium octyl sulfate (SOS) in a 3:7 mole ratio or octyltrimethylammonium bromide (OTAB) and SDS in a 7:3 mole ratio. The remaining surfactant vesicle was comprised solely of bis(2-ethylhexyl)sodium sulfosuccinate (AOT) in 10% v/v methanol, and the phospholipid vesicle consisted of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) and phosphatidyl serine (PS) in 8:2 mole ratio. The mean diameters of the vesicles were 76.3 nm (AOT), 86.9 nm (CTAB/SOS), 90.1 nm (OTAB/SDS), and 108 nm (POPC/PS). Whereas the coefficient of electroosmotic flow (10(-4) cm2 V(-1) s(-1)) varied considerably (1.72 (OTAB/SDS), 3.77 (CTAB/SOS), 4.05 (AOT), 5.26 (POPC/PS), 5.31 (SDS)), the electrophoretic mobility was fairly consistent (-3.33 to -3.87 x 10(-4) cm2 V(-1) s(-1)), except for the OTAB/SDS vesicles (-1.68). This resulted in elution ranges that were slightly to significantly larger than that observed for SDS (3.12): 3.85 (POPC/PS), 8.6 (CTAB/SOS), 10.1 (AOT), 15.2 (OTAB/SDS). Significant differences were also noted in the efficiency (using propiophenone) and hydrophobic selectivity; the plate counts were lower with the OTAB/SDS and POPC/PS vesicles than the other pseudostationary phases (< or = 75,000/m vs. > 105,000/m), and the methylene selectivity was considerably higher with the CTAB/SOS and OTAB/SDS vesicles compared to the others (ca. 3.10 vs. < or = 2.6). In terms of shape selectivity, only the CTAB/SOS vesicles were able to separate all three positional isomers of nitrotoluene with near-baseline resolution. Finally, through LSER analysis, it was determined that the cohesiveness and hydrogen bond acidity of these pseudostationary phases have the greatest effect on solute retention and selectivity.