Characterization and discrimination of paleokarst breccias and pseudobreccias in carbonate rocks: Insight from Ordovician strata in the northern Tarim Basin, China

Abstract

Ordovician carbonates in the central and southern Halahatang area of the Tarim Basin host highly productive hydrocarbon reservoirs. Previous studies suggest that the Yingshan and Yijianfang Formations (the primary producing intervals) have been extensively karstified. However, the current author has not observed significant karst features in the formations based on the detailed study of 380 m long cores from 16 wells. In the current study, true breccias are only identified in two wells in the Lianglitage Formation, including crackle and mosaic breccias as well as chaotic, clast-supported breccias. The breccias are interpreted as karst-related breccias that formed in near-surface environments during pre-Silurian subaerial exposure, and timing of karstification probably coincided with eustatic sea-level fall caused by the middle Katian glaciation. Widespread “karst features” of the Yijianfang and Yingshan Formations identified as breccias or sediment-filled cavities in many previous studies are actually only a mottled fabric (pseudobreccia) caused by selective diagenetic alteration and infiltration of bitumen in the deeper subsurface. The color difference between pseudoclasts and pseudomatrix does not reflect a mixture of clasts and cave sediments, but instead is characterized by distinct, nevertheless commonly subtle, variations in the limestone texture and whether bitumen is present. One the basis of core and thin section observations, SEM (scanning electron microscope) and XRD (X-ray diffraction) analyses, the author presents criteria to distinguish karst breccias and pseudobreccias that can be applied to other similar carbonate deposits. Discrimination between karst breccias and nodular limestones is also presented. Differentiation of karst and pseudokarst features serves not only an academic interest, but also has important applications for the exploration and development of carbonate reservoirs.