Changes in valgus and varus alignment neutralize aberrant frontal plane knee moments in patients with unicompartmental knee osteoarthritis

Abstract

To elucidate the effects of frontal plane lower limb alignment on gait biomechanics, we compared knee joint moments and frontal plane angular impulse before and after varus or valgus producing osteotomy in patients with lateral or medial compartment osteoarthritis, and in healthy participants with neutral alignment. Thirty-nine subjects participated (13 valgus gonarthrosis, 13 varus gonarthrosis, 13 controls). Patients underwent 3D gait analysis and radiographic assessment of alignment (mechanical axis angle; MAA) before and 6 months after surgery, and were compared to controls. Mean changes (95%CI) in frontal plane angular impulse indicated a 0.82%BW·Ht·s (0.49,1.14) increase in adduction impulse in patients after varus osteotomy, and a 0.61%BW·Ht·s (0.37,0.86) decrease in adduction impulse in patients after valgus osteotomy, equating to a 53% and 45% change from preoperative values, respectively. Preoperative frontal plane angular impulse was significantly different between both patient groups and controls before surgery, but not after. The cross-sectional data suggest that frontal plane angular impulse is very highly correlated to MAA before surgery (R=0.87), but not after (R=0.39), and that an adduction impulse predominates until 7° of valgus, at which point an abduction impulse predominates. The prospective surgical realignment data indicate that for every 1° change in MAA toward varus, there is a 0.1%BW·Ht·s (or 1.6Nms) change in frontal plane knee angular impulse toward adduction, and vice versa. These overall findings illustrate the potent effects that lower limb alignment can have on frontal plane gait biomechanics.