Changes in guilt cognitions in intensive PTSD treatment among veterans who experienced military sexual trauma or combat trauma

Abstract

Unresolved trauma-related guilt has been identified as a factor that can intensify posttraumatic stress disorder PTSD symptomology and is associated with many negative mental health outcomes. Evidence-based treatments, such as Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT), have been shown to successfully reduce trauma-related guilt. However, less is known about how trauma-related guilt cognitions change over the course of PTSD treatment and, more specifically, intensive PTSD treatments. The current study examined whether guilt cognitions (i.e., hindsight bias/responsibility, insufficient justification, wrongdoing) changed over the course of a 3-week CPT-based intensive treatment program (ITP), whether guilt cognition changes predicted PTSD and depression symptom reductions over time, and whether guilt cognition changes and their association with PTSD and depression symptom changes differed based on whether they worked on combat trauma or military sexual trauma. Data were collected from 360 veterans enrolled in a 3-week ITP. Results from linear mixed effects models suggested that trauma-related guilt cognitions reduced significantly over the course of treatment (ps < .001), changes in wrongdoing (p = .032) and hindsight bias/responsibility (p = .003) were significant predictors of PTSD symptom reductions and hindsight bias/responsibility (p = .032) was the only significant predictor of depression symptom reduction. Overall differences in guilt cognitions over time based on cohort type were only significant for insufficient justification (p = .001). These findings suggest that changes in hindsight bias/responsibility demonstrated the largest effect size (d = 0.1.14), implying that hindsight bias/responsibility may be one of the most important guilt cognitions to target. This study also highlights the importance of the relationship between trauma-related guilt and PTSD and depression symptoms. Future research should examine whether changes in guilt cognitions precede changes in PTSD and depression symptoms, and if addressing certain types of guilt cognitions is more important to achieving PTSD and depression symptom reductions.