Challenging Orthodoxy: beyond the Critical View of Safety

Abstract

BackgroundThe critical view of safety (CVS) is the gold standard for performing safe cholecystectomies and minimizing common bile duct (CBD) injuries. It requires three criteria: complete clearance of the hepatocystic triangle, partial separation of the gallbladder from the cystic plate, and two structures alone entering the gallbladder. However, biliary anatomy varies widely, with frequent aberrant arterial supplies, which can mislead or disorient those attempting to acquire the CVS. This study was designed to examine the nature and frequency of cystic artery anatomic anomalies. MethodsWe conducted a prospective observational study from 2018 to 2020, compiling photos of the critical view of safety of 100 consecutive elective cholecystectomies performed at our institution. Gallbladders were dissected up to the parallel portion of the cystic plate to achieve a critical view of safety. All tubular structures were preserved and clipped. Operative reports were examined for mention of posterior cystic arteries or aberrant arterial supplies. Photos were reviewed for an adequate critical view of the safety and presence of aberrant arterial supplies. The rate of aberrant arterial supply was determined and photos were reviewed for patterns of common abnormalities. ResultsThere were 121 patients who underwent an elective cholecystectomy; 21 lacked intraoperative pictures and were excluded from the study. Of the 100 patients included, 57 (57%) had an aberrant arterial supply with more than one cystic artery; seven had three concurrent arteries. Of those with more than one cystic artery, 21% had a recurrent cystic artery, 21% had a posterior dominant cystic artery, and 12% had a low-branching anterior cystic artery. ConclusionEven with appropriate dissection for the CVS, surgeons can expect to frequently visualize more than two structures entering the gallbladder when a posterior cystic artery is present. It is, therefore, integral to distinguish this aberrant anatomy to prevent inadvertent injury to the CBD.