Challenges in creating the educated surgeon in the 21st century: where do we stand?

Abstract

LettersChallenges in creating the educated surgeon in the 21st century: Where do we stand? Gamal KhairyFRCS, MS, FBS Gamal Khairy Search for more papers by this author Published Online:3 Jun 2004https://doi.org/10.5144/0256-4947.2004.218aSectionsPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload citationTrack citations ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmail AboutIntroductionTo the Editor: Improved performance, which remains a constant concern in the health service and places a heavy burden and responsibility on health planners, has become an increasingly difficult task in view of the fast changes in society in general and medicine in particular.1 The rate of change in medicine nowadays resembles those associated with the Industrial Revolution in England, 150 years ago.2 In the field of surgery, two major changes have occurred: the increasing importance of less invasive technologies, and the growing awareness of the importance of “systems” in surgical care. To cope with these challenges, the traditional educational strategies in surgery need to be altered to keep pace with recent developments in minimally invasive surgery.We examined problems in the current surgical residency training programme (SRTP) at King Khalid University Hospital (KKUH) by two approaches: 1) a quantitative semi-structured focus group study conducted through direct contact with the individuals involved in the SRTP, including 11 residents, 3 programme directors, and 7 consultants involved in the training and education of the trainees, and 2) a review of the literature on problems in surgical education and training, using a computer-based literature search (Medline).Most of the residents in the current surgical training program agreed that there are a limited number of clinical cases for practice and training, and that they are not satisfied with the quantity and quality of operations they are performing during their training as first surgeons. They also think that a resident off-day and a study leave should be made mandatory to enable them to attend conferences, symposia and surgical courses. Programme directors and consultants emphasized that the number of cases for practice and training of residents is small. They think that our senior surgical residents do not show full competence after graduation and cannot be relied upon to perform many major operations with confidence. They suggested that effort should be made to find alternatives in training to fill the current deficiencies and to cope with the shortage in clinical cases. They also emphasized importance of one-to-one contact, especially for the junior residents.The decreasing patient population continues to be a major concern in many other surgical programmes7 and has created a need for formal training outside the operating theatre.8,9 The lack of full competence in graduate surgical residents has also been documented in other programmes.10–11 Weigett et al11 in 1998, in a large survey of 954 general surgeons involved in the training of surgical residents, concluded that changes were needed because the current system of resident education allows chief residents to graduate with significant deficiencies in their education. Alternatives have been suggested for many surgical programmes,12–15 but not in our programme. There is very little locoregional data regarding the current surgical residency training programmes to reflect such problems and then to raise proposals to improve performance and outcome.Medical education continues to face pressure to re-engineer itself. These pressures include the decreasing patient population at academic medical centers, competing care systems, correlating student output with market needs, identifying the best way to train physicians, and the best location for training.16–21 Rapid developments in technology have generated an increasing need to develop methods of technical skills instruction outside the operating theaters, in the form of courses or workshops,24 which are now considered a mainstay of continuing education programmes for surgeons. Some training programmes provide sporadic teaching and practice opportunities for their residents outside the operating room.25,26 Lossing et al, detailed the technical skills programme for first-year residents in general surgery,25 which consisted of introductory didactic sessions and wet labs. The latter included instructions on the preparation of the patient and draping, aseptic technique, the principles of bowel anastomosis, incisions, the use and handling of instruments, principles of hemostasis, intraoperative surgical emergencies, surgical assisting and theatre etiquette. The live animal has often been used for providing living simulations.25,27,28 Bench models, which are becoming popular for teaching specific surgical skills,29–33 have the advantages of low cost, portability, ability to use in an unsupervised practice, and they provide unlimited practice for residents. The feasibility of residency bench and wet laboratory training in essential technical skills in a human cadaver model has been demonstrated.24–25 Descôteaux and Leclère34 have summarized the theories and principles of motor skill learning as they apply to surgical training. Thomas et al35 concluded that synthetic tissues can provide a useful and functionally reproducible means for learning basic surgical skills. It must be emphasized that the introduction of laparoscopic techniques made the teaching of operative skills more difficult, due to many factors, including the complexity of the procedure, the time required in teaching, and medicolegal concerns. Nonetheless, Rossers have shown that concentrated didactic training in laparoscopy in a brief course unrelated to prior surgical experience can improve skills in both residents and established surgeons.36Advances in computing, imaging and information transfer have allowed the use of virtual reality in the performance and teaching of surgery.37 For example, the minimally invasive surgery–trainer virtual reality (MIST-VR) system allows tasks to be performed using laparoscopic instruments connected to a computer, where the movement of the instruments can be both measured and translated into a graphical display.38 Anaesthesiologists have pioneered the use of operating room simulators to improve crises management skills.39 Such methods will help overcome problems of decreasing number of clinical cases in medical teaching centers and the increasing importance of minimal access surgery. In this way, we will have in our hands practical and convenient methods that can be applied in our surgical training programme to overcome similar problems.The traditional educational strategies in the current surgical training programme need to be changed to cope with recent developments in minimally invasive surgery, and the decreasing number of clinical cases in medical education centers. The need for change should first be confirmed by surveying surgical consultants involved in the training and education of surgical residents, and obtaining their feedback.ARTICLE REFERENCES:1. Lowrence W. "General surgery in evolution: Technology and competence" . The Am J Surg. 1996; 171:2-9. Google Scholar2. Mazlish B. "The fourth discontinuity" . The co-evaluation of humans and machines. New Haven, Conn: Yale University Press; 1993. Google Scholar3. Flexner A. Medical Education in the United States and Canada. New York: Camegie Foundation for the advancement of teaching; 1910. Google Scholar4. Hamdorf JM, Hall JC. "Acquiring surgical skills" . Br J Surg. 2000; 87:28-37. Google Scholar5. McColl I. "The Guy’s surgical training programme: A report of the first 5 years" . Br J Surg. 1977; 64:745-746. Google Scholar6. Cushieri A. "Whither minimal access surgery: tribulations and expectations" . Am J Surg. 1995; 269:9-19. Google Scholar7. Steele RJC, Logie JRC, Munro A. "Technical training in surgery: The trainees view" . Br J Surg. 1989; 76:1291-1293. Google Scholar8. MacIntyne IMC, Munro A. "Simulation in surgical training: Trainee surgeons need to acquire skills outside the operating theater" . BMJ. 1990; 30:1089-1099. Google Scholar9. Andreopoulos S. "The folly of teaching–hospital merges" . N Eng J Med. 1997; 336:61-64. Google Scholar10. Wheeler HB. "Myth and reality in general surgery" . Bull Am Coll Surg. 1993; 78:21. Google Scholar11. Weigelt J, Brasel K, Olson C, Thal E. "Opinions of practicing general surgeons on surgical education" . Am J Surg. 1998; 176:481-85. Google Scholar12. Barnes RW. "Surgical handicraft: teaching and learning surgical skill" . Am J Surg. 1987; 153:422-427. Google Scholar13. Pories WJ, Aslakson HM. "The surgical residency: The job description does not fit the job" . Arch Surg. 1990; 125:147-149. Google Scholar14. Barnes RW. "The next generation of surgical residents: What are the challenges and the opportunities?" Arch Surg. 1990; 125:433-436. Google Scholar15. Folse JR. "Presidential address: Surgical education–addressing the challenges of change" . Surgery. 1996; 120:575-579. Google Scholar16. Ritchie WP. "Graduate surgical education in the era of managed care: A statement from the American Board of Surgery" . J Am Coll Surg. 1997; 184:311-312. Google Scholar17. Fox PD, Wasserman J. "Academic medical centers and managed care: Uneasy partners" . Health Affairs. 1993; 12:85-93. Google Scholar18. Flint L, Flint CB. "Academic surgical group practices at the dawn of health reform" . Ann Surg. 1994; 220:374-381. Google Scholar19. Pories WJ, Smout JC, Morris A, Lewkow VE. "U.S. Health care reform: will it change postgraduate surgical education?" World J Surg. 1994; 18:745-752. Google Scholar20. Elliot DW. "Presidential address: Outsiders in surgical education–are the voluntary faculty worth more than they are paid?" Surgery. 1988; 104:585-591. Google Scholar21. Ward HB, MacCanley MK, Foker JE. "The ivory tower from outside and in: A survey of Minnesota surgeons" . Surgery. 1993; 114:436-441. Google Scholar22. Porter N. Webster’s revised unabridged dictionary. Springfield, MA: G and Merriam Co; 1913. Google Scholar23. Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, 10th ed. Springfield, MA: Merriam Websters, Inc; 1998. Google Scholar24. Anastakis J, Regehr G, Resznick RK, Cusimano M, Murnaghan J, Brown M, Hutchison C. "Assessment of technical skills transfer from the bench training model to the human model" . Am J Surg. 1999; 177:167-170. Google Scholar25. Lossing AG, Hatswell EM, Gilas T, et al. "A technical-skills course for 1st-year residents in general surgery. A descriptive study" . Can J Surg. 1992; 35:536-540. Google Scholar26. Heppell J, Beaucamp G, Chollet A. "10-year experience with a basic technical skills and perioperative management workshop for first-year residents" . Can J Surg. 1995; 38:27-32. Google Scholar27. Sain J, Chang BB, Paty PSK, et al. "An animal model for instructing and the study of in situ bypass" . J Vasc Surg. 1990; 12:538-540. Google Scholar28. Christopherson WA, Buchsbaum HJ, Voet R, Lifshitz S. "The canine laboratory in the training of Oncology fellow" . Gynecol Oncol. 1986; 23:26-34. Google Scholar29. Stotter AT, Becket AJ, Hansen JPR, et al. "Simulation in surgical training using freeze-dried material" . Br J Surg. 1986; 73:53-54. Google Scholar30. Barnes RW, Lang NP, Whiteside MF. "Halstaedian technique revisited. Innovations in teaching surgical skills" . Ann Surg. 1989; 210:118-121. Google Scholar31. Hill J, Kiff ES. "An abdominal wall jig for surgical craft workshops" . Ann Roy Coll Surg Engl. 1990; 72:386-387. Google Scholar32. Sammaro MJ, Youngblood JP. "A resident teaching programme in operative surgery" . Obstet Gynaecol. 1993; 81:463-466. Google Scholar33. Steel RJC, Walder C, Herbert M. "Psychomotor testing and the ability to perform an anastomosis in junior surgical trainees" . Br J Surg. 1992; 79:1065-1067. Google Scholar34. Descôteaux J, Leclère H. "Learning surgical technical skills" . Can J Surg. 1995; 38:33-38. Google Scholar35. Thomas WEG, Lee PWR, Sunderland GT, Day RP. "A preliminary evaluation of an innovative synthetic soft tissue module (skill tray) for use in basic surgical skills workshops" . Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1996; 78(Suppl 6):268-71. Google Scholar36. Rosser JC, Rosser LE, Saving RS. "Objective evaluation of a laparoscopic surgical skills programme for residents and senior surgeons" . Arch Surg. 1998; 133:657-61. Google Scholar37. Dunnington GL, DaRosa DA. "Changing surgical education strategies in an environment of changing health care delivery systems" . World J Surg. 1994; 18:734-7. Google Scholar38. Stone RJ, McCloy RF. "Virtual environment training systems for laparoscopic surgery: activities at the UK’s Wolfson Centre for minimally invasive therapy" . Journal of Medical Virtual Reality. 1996; 1:42-51. Google Scholar39. Goba DM, Howard SK, Flanagan B, et al. "Assessment of clinical performance during simulated crises using both technical and behavioral ratings" . Anaesthesiology. 1998; 89:8-18. Google Scholar Previous article Next article FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Volume 24, Issue 3May-June 2004 Metrics History Published online3 June 2004 InformationCopyright © 2004, Annals of Saudi MedicineThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.PDF download