Cerebral hemorrhage caused by shaking adult syndrome? Evidence from biomechanical analysis using 3D motion capture and finite element models.

Abstract

The present study combined three-dimensional (3D) motion capture with finite element simulation to reconstruct a real shaking adult syndrome (SAS) case and further explore the injury biomechanics of SAS. The frequency at which an adult male can shake the head of another person, head-shaking amplitude, and displacement curves was captured by the VICON 3D motion capture system. The captured shaking frequency and shaking curve were loaded on the total human model for safety (THUMS) head to simulate the biomechanical response of brain injury when a head was shaken in anterior-posterior, left-right, and left anterior-right posterior directions at frequencies of 4Hz (Hz), 5Hz, 6Hz, and 7Hz. The biomechanical response of the head on impact in the anterior, posterior, left, left anterior, and right posterior directions at the equivalent velocity of 6Hz shaking was simulated. The violent shaking frequency of the adult male was 3.2-6.8Hz; head shaking at these frequencies could result in serious cerebral injuries. SAS-related injuries have obvious directionality, and sagittal shaking can easily cause brain injuries. There was no significant difference between the brain injuries caused by shaking in the simulated frequency range (4-7Hz). Impact and shaking at an equivalent velocity could cause brain injuries, though SAS more commonly occurred due to the cumulative deformation of brain tissue. Biomechanical studies of SAS should play a positive role in improving the accuracy of forensic identification and reducing this form of abuse and torture in detention or places of imprisonment.