Cerebral Aneurysm Wall Stress After Coiling Depends on Morphology and Coil Packing Density.

Abstract

Endovascular coil embolization is now widely used to treat cerebral aneurysms (CA) as an alternative to surgical clipping. It involves filling the aneurysmal sac with metallic coils to reduce flow, induce clotting, and promote the formation of a coil/thrombus mass which protects the aneurysm wall from hemodynamic forces and prevents rupture. However, a significant number of aneurysms are incompletely coiled leading to aneurysm regrowth and/or recanalization. Computational models of aneurysm coiling may provide important new insights into the effects of intrasaccular coil and thrombus on aneurysm wall stresses. Porcine blood and platinum coils were used to construct an in vitro coil thrombus mass (CTM) for mechanical testing. A uniaxial compression test was performed with whole blood clots and CTM, with coil packing densities (CPDs) of 10%, 20%, and 30% to obtain compressive stress/strain responses. A fourth-order polynomial mechanical response function was fit to the experimentally obtained stress/strain responses for each CPD in order to represent their mechanical properties for computational simulations. Patient-specific three-dimensional (3D) geometries of three aneurysms with simple geometry and four with complex geometry were reconstructed from digital subtraction angiography (DSA) images. The CPDs were digitally inserted in the aneurysm geometries and finite element modeling was used to determine transmural peak/mean wall stress (MWS) with and without coil packing. Reproducible stress/strain curves were obtained from compression testing of CTM and the polynomial mechanical response function was found to approximate the experimental stress/strain relationship obtained from mechanical testing to a high degree. An exponential increase in the CTM stiffness was observed with increasing CPD. Elevated wall stresses were found throughout the aneurysm dome, neck, and parent artery in simulations of the CAs with no filling. Complete, 100% filling of the aneurysms with whole blood clot and CPDs of 10%, 20%, and 30% significantly reduced MWS in simple and complex geometry aneurysms. Sequential increases in CPD resulted in significantly greater increases in MWS in simple but not complex geometry aneurysms. This study utilizes finite element analysis to demonstrate the reduction of transmural wall stress following coil embolization in patient-specific computational models of CAs. Our results provide a quantitative measure of the degree to which CPD impacts wall stress and suggest that complex aneurysmal geometries may be more resistant to coil embolization treatment. The computational modeling employed in this study serves as a first step in developing a tool to evaluate the patient-specific efficacy of coil embolization in treating CAs.