CD5-negative blastoid variant mantle cell lymphoma: a diagnostic dilemma

Abstract

We encountered two cases of CD5- blastoid variant mantle cell lymphoma (MCL), prompting us to investigate the proportion of CD5 negativity in MCL and assess the diagnosis of aggressive MCL variants. Among 117 patients diagnosed with MCL, CD5 negativity was observed in 13% (13/104) of cases with classical MCL and 15% (2/13) of cases with blastoid/pleomorphic variant MCL. Of the aggressive MCL variant cases, tumor cells exhibited intermediate nuclear size and required differential diagnosis between blastoid variant and classical MCL in six patients, and classical MCL cells were found in the background of aggressive variant tumors or in other sites in six patients. Of 1534 patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL), CD5 positivity was observed in 8% (121/1534) of cases. Immunohistochemical staining for cyclin D1 performed for these cases revealed one cyclin D1-positive and IGH/CCND1 fusion-positive case (0.9%, 1/114), namely pleomorphic variant MCL. Of the remaining 1413 patients initially diagnosed with CD5- DLBCL, the diagnoses of two patients (0.1%) were amended to CD5- blastoid variant MCL in the relapse phase based on morphology, cyclin D1 immunostaining, and fluorescence in situ hybridization. The incidence of CD5 negativity was similar between classical MCL and two aggressive variants. Accurate diagnosis of MCL variants was enabled by identifying a classical MCL component and/or CD5 positivity; however, we misdiagnosed two cases of CD5- blastoid variant MCL. A small number of MCL variants may be included in CD5- DLBCL cases. The diagnosis of CD5- aggressive variant MCL remains challenging but crucial because of its therapeutic significance.