CBCT artefact-burden of zirconia-based as compared to titanium implants for different beam energies: an analytical approach

Abstract

Beam hardening artefacts induced by highly-dense material (e.g. metal) is a common quality issue in maxillofacial Cone Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT-) images. This experimental and analytical study investigated attenuation patterns of two typical dental implant materials: zirconia-ceramic and pure titanium. By application of different x-ray beam energies (60, 70, 80, 90 [kVp]) energy-dependent attenuation of these materials is assessed and the resulting artefact induction in the resulting CBCT-images evaluated. A zirconia (Y-TZP-) implant (varnothing: 4.1 mm) and a pure titanium rod (varnothing: 4.0 mm) were exposed in a commercial CBCT (3D Accuitomo 170). The raw two-dimensional (2D) projection radiographs the CBCT utilizes for three-dimensional reconstruction applied for acquisition of attenuation profiles through the circular central slice of the implant-phantom images. Distances the x-rays traverse through the implant-phantoms at this location were computed. Using this information and the linear attenuation coefficient, transmission and attenuation was computed for each material and beam energy. These data were related to beam hardening artefacts that were assessed in the axial reconstructions of the implants’ CBCT images. Transmission of titanium for all peak kilovoltages (kVp) was higher and approximately 200% that of Y-TZP at 60 kVp versus 530% at 90 kVp. At 4 mm diameter transmission for Y-TZP was only approximately 5 % for all four beam-energies. In agreement with this finding, beam hardening artefacts for Y-TZP could not be reduced using higher energies, whereas for titanium they decreased with increasing energy. For the energy spectrum used in this study (60–90 kVp), beam hardening caused by titanium can be reduced using higher energies while this is not the case for zirconia-ceramic (Y-TZP).