Carboniferous Manning Canyon Formation, northern Utah, USA: A carbonate-mud-dominated cyclothem motif recording the main onset of the late Paleozoic Ice Age

Abstract

A poorly understood Mississippian to basal Pennsylvanian succession is preserved in parts of northern Utah, western USA. The mudrock- and carbonate-dominated Manning Canyon Formation and lateral equivalents have been referred to as “cyclothems” and might therefore be expected to preserve a record of repeated, late Paleozoic sea-level excursions similar to cyclothemic successions elsewhere in the paleotropics. In this paper, we document the sedimentology and stratigraphy of the Serpukhovian to earliest Bashkirian Manning Canyon Formation, focusing on surface exposures in the Oquirrh and Uinta Mountains and a cored subsurface intersection from central Utah. Four facies associations were identified in the Manning Canyon Formation: Mid-Shelf, Muddy Inner Shelf, Deltaic, and Coastal Plain, which are herein interpreted in the context of a muddy, semi-enclosed, epicontinental carbonate shelf fringed by a low-relief coastal plain. These facies associations are broadly comparable to recent and extant environments from a range of equatorial, clay-rich, deltaic, coastal plain, and offshore carbonate-producing environments in the Caribbean Sea, northern Australia, and SE Asia, which can be used as first-order analogues for the Manning Canyon Formation. These modern analogues suggest that several relative sea-level excursions of <40 m are recorded in the unit. The stratigraphically oldest records of substantial relative sea-level oscillations are in the lowermost Manning Canyon Formation. These preceded a more sustained pattern recorded by at least nine 4th-order, high-frequency and high-magnitude (≥40 m) sea-level cycles that characterize the upper two-thirds of the formation. Sea-level highstands are recorded by open marine shelf facies, whereas lowstands are recorded by incised channel and valley fills, and (presumed) laterally equivalent paleosols and thin coals. No record of high frequency/high magnitude relative sea-level oscillations comparable in character to those preserved in the Manning Canyon Formation was documented in the underlying stratigraphy. It is concluded that the Manning Canyon Formation may record the main onset of the eustatic signal associated with the main phase of the late Paleozoic Ice Age at ~330 Ma.