Can isoprenoids in leaves and roots of plants serve as biomarkers for past vegetation changes? A case study from the Ecuadorian Andes

Abstract

Large-scale clear-cutting and burning caused the altitude of the natural upper forest line (UFL) in the Northern Ecuadorian Andes to decline to the point that its ‘natural’ position is now uncertain. To obtain a detailed reconstruction of the dynamics of the UFL over the last few thousand years, traditional proxies alone do not suffice. For instance, pollen analysis suffers from a low altitudinal resolution due to the large wind-blown component. In an attempt to find new, additional proxies to study past UFL dynamics in the Ecuadorian Andes, we investigated the occurrence of isoprenoids (diterpenes, phytosterols and pentacyclic triterpenoids) in the roots and leaves of 19 plant species responsible for the dominant biomass input in soil and peat records along altitudinal transects covering approximately 500 m above and below the current UFL in two locations in the Northern Ecuadorian Andes. Isoprenoids can serve as biomarker if they are uniquely present in a relevant plant species and preserved well enough in chronological order in suitable records. Such biomarkers could help establish past vegetation dynamics including the UFL position. For an isoprenoid to be a biomarker in soils normally it must be absent from the roots of a plant species as roots do not enter soils in chronological order. For peat deposits this criteria only needs to be met for the peat species themselves as only roots from peat species will be present. Two diterpenes, four phytosterols and six pentacyclic triterpenoids met the criteria for biomarker in peat records. Of these, one diterpene, two phytosterols and three pentacyclic triterpenoids also met the criteria for biomarker in soils. Samples from a soil under forest, a soil under the adjacent paramo and a nearby peat deposit, 14C dated at approximately 1500 cal. AD and 200 cal. AD, were tested for the presence of isoprenoids that meet the criteria for biomarker. Such isoprenoids were only found in the peat bog samples. However, we found that changes of number and concentrations of isoprenoids with depth might provide additional information related to past vegetation changes. In conclusion, isoprenoids show potential for use in a multi-proxy approach to reconstruct past UFL locations in the Northern Ecuadorian Andes and other ecosystems with similar vegetation and soils.