Can incorporating molecular testing improve the accuracy of newborn screening for congenital adrenal hyperplasia?

Abstract

Single-tier newborn screening (NBS) for CAH using 17-hydroxyprogesterone (17OHP) measured by fluoroimmunoassay (FIA) in samples collected at 24-48 hours produces a high false-positive rate (FPR). 2nd tier steroid testing can reduce the FPR and has been widely implemented. We investigated the accuracy of an alternative multi-tier CAH NBS protocol that incorporates molecular testing of the CYP21A2 gene and reduces the 1st tier 17OHP cutoff to minimize missed cases. Created a Minnesota-specific CYP21A2 pathogenic variants panel; develop a rapid, high-throughput multiplex, allele-specific-primer-extension assay; perform 1-year retrospective analysis of Minnesota NBS results comparing metrics between a conventional steroid-based two-tier protocol and a molecular-based multi-tier NBS protocol, applied post-hoc. CYP21A2 gene sequencing of 103 Minnesota families resulted in a Minnesota-specific panel of 21 pathogenic variants. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) created a molecular assay with 100% accuracy and reproducibility. Two-tier steroid-based screening of 68,659 live births during 2015 resulted in 2 false negatives (FNs), 91 FPs, and 1 true positive (TP). A three-tier protocol with a lower 1st-tier steroid cutoff, 2nd-tier 21-variant CYP21A2 panel and 3rd-tier CYP21A2 sequencing would have resulted in 0 FNs, 52 FPs and 3 TPs. Incorporation of molecular testing could improve the accuracy of CAH NBS, although some distinct challenges of molecular testing may need to be considered before implementation by NBS programs.