Calcium isotope variability among ocean islands reveals the physical and lithological controls on mantle partial melting

Abstract

Major geodynamic processes, including mantle convection and plate tectonics, govern the exchange of mass between Earth's interior and its surface. These processes drive mass-transfer mechanisms such as partial melting and crustal recycling, which have generated a lithologically and compositionally heterogeneous mantle over time. Ocean island basalts (OIB) directly sample these heterogeneities, making them excellent tools to constrain the mantle’s dynamic geochemical evolution. In this study, we probe the connection between crustal recycling, mantle mineralogy, and partial melting using the stable Ca isotope compositions of OIB, ultimately contextualizing their Ca isotope variability using conventional mantle “endmember” components including DMM, HIMU, EM-1, and EM-2. Using the state-of-the-art Nu Sapphire collision cell MC-ICP-MS, we measured the Ca isotope compositions of 27 well-characterized OIB samples from 11 different ocean island groups. By supplementing our new data with additional high-precision Ca isotope measurements from the literature, we create an expanded dataset consisting of 15 ocean islands, facilitating a global-scale investigation of Ca isotope variability among hotspots. Our findings reveal that island-averaged Ca isotope compositions form two distinct groups on the basis of their radiogenic isotope compositions. The first group, consisting of OIB with un-enriched radiogenic isotope compositions (non-EM-type), exhibits robust negative correlations with both lithospheric thickness and primitive TiO2 contents, providing compelling evidence that Ca isotopes are sensitive to the degree of partial melting (F) as well as to the effects of crustal recycling. This joint signal appears to trace the process of decompression melting beneath oceanic lithosphere of variable thickness, as recycled lithologies rich in garnet and pyroxene (i.e., pyroxenites)—which generate large solid-melt Ca isotope fractionations—disproportionally control the Ca isotope composition of the final aggregate melt when F is limited by thick overlying lithosphere. In contrast, the island-averaged Ca isotope compositions of OIB with enriched radiogenic isotope compositions (EM-type) form a distinctly light negative correlation with primitive TiO2 contents without exhibiting a relationship with lithospheric thickness. In addition to lithology-dependent partial melting effects, the Ca isotope compositions of EM-type OIB appear to be sensitive to the compositional effects of crustal recycling, which may explain their decoupling from the physical controls of partial melting. Calcium isotopes show exceptional potential for elucidating the origin of both enriched and ultra-depleted mantle sources, emphasizing the need to prioritize localities with these signatures in future studies.