Calcium isotope fractionation associated with adsorption and desorption on/from δ-MnO2

Abstract

Small mineral particles present in soils, such as clay minerals and some oxyhydroxides, constitute important nutrient reservoirs. This behavior is due to the negative charges and high specific surface areas of these particles allowing them to adsorb cations such as calcium (Ca), a macronutrient that occupies key physiological and structural functions in plant metabolism. Although the chemical reactivity of clay minerals is rather well-known in the literature, especially toward macronutrients such as Ca, that of oxyhydroxides such as phyllomanganate minerals remains largely unexplored.To enhance our understanding of the mechanisms at the origin of the storage/release of the different isotopes of Ca in a soil solution, the possible fractionation between 40Ca and 44Ca during adsorption and desorption of Ca on a synthetic phyllomanganate, abiotically precipitated in the laboratory [synthetic analog of vernadite (δ-MnO2)], was studied. Experiments were performed in batch (closed system), and several parameters (time, pH of the solution, Ca concentration and nature and concentration of the desorbent) were tested to cover a large range of physicochemical conditions.This study demonstrated that the light 40Ca isotope is preferentially adsorbed on δ-MnO2, with Δ44/40Ca (the apparent fractionation of the aqueous solution at the stationnary state of adsorption compared to the initial one) of the adsorbed Ca that can reach 1.19 ± 0.15‰. The results showed that this isotopic fractionation occurs at chemical equilibrium in a closed system and that the isotopic fractionation measured in this study during Ca adsorption on phyllomanganate is significantly higher than that reported in the literature during Ca adsorption on other soil constituents such as clay minerals. At pH below 4 Ca occupies only the interlayer/basal sites whereas above this pH Ca fills interlayer/basal sites (∼86%) and edges sites (∼14%). By combining the experimental data obtained at different pH values, initial Ca concentrations and interaction times, our results suggest that isotopic signature of the Ca adsorbed on δ-MnO2 is dependent on the nature of the site involved in the adsorption step (i.e., enriched in 40Ca in the interlayer with Δ44/40Ca equal to −0.43‰ and enriched in 44Ca when bound to the edges with Δ44/40Ca equal to +3.5‰). As revealed by surface complexation modeling, such contrasting behavior between the two types of adsorption sites could be due to the bidendate nature of the Ca adsorption occurring on edges and to ion exchange of Ca2+ with H+ in the interlayer sites. Finally, desorption experiments point to total but not instantaneous Ca desorption, probably due to a partial collapse of the interlayer with some ions used to desorb Ca2+ (K+, NH4+, hexaamine-cobalt). This suggests that the amount of bioavailable Ca in soils by simple ion-exchange reactions is highly dependent on the nature of the ions which could desorb Ca present in the soil solution.