Bridging the gap from implementation to attainment: Utilising results from international comparative studies

Surette Van Staden

doi:10.4102/satnt.v35i1.1304

Abstract

South African learner performance in international comparative studies remains persistently poor, resulting in questions about the quality of education offered to South African children across grades and phases of formal schooling. In South Africa, grave concerns with regard to low levels of learner achievement pervade research initiatives and educational debates. Despite good intentions (such as policy and curricular reforms) and focus on implementation (such as curriculum provision and teacher support), attainment (in the form of learner achievement) remain disappointingly low. This study draws on the preProgress in International Reading Literacy Study (prePIRLS) 2011 data, which places South African Grade 4 learners’ results at 461, which is substantially below the international centre point of 500 (SE = 3.7). Results from the prePIRLS 2011 study are used as evidence of curricular attainment that has taken place at Grade 4 level across a spectrum of 11 languages in South Africa. Benchmark results are further interrogated to provide evidence for possible improvement of curricular implementation at classroom level. Concluding remarks include reflections of how teacher practice can benefit from evidence provided by international comparative studies.

Highlights

Die prestasies van Suid-Afrikaanse leerders in internasionaal vergelykende studies bly voortdurend swak, wat vrae laat ontstaan oor die kwaliteit van onderwys wat aan SuidAfrikaanse kinders gebied word in die verskillende grade en fases van formele skoolonderrig
Ernstige kommer oor leerders se swak prestasies oorheers navorsing en opvoedkundige debatte in Suid-Afrika
South African learner performance in international comparative studies remains persistently poor, resulting in questions about the quality of education offered to South African children across grades and phases of formal schooling

Summary

Oorspronklike Navorsing

Van implementering tot verwesentliking: Aanwending van resultate van internasionaal vergelykende studies. Die prestasies van Suid-Afrikaanse leerders in internasionaal vergelykende studies bly voortdurend swak, wat vrae laat ontstaan oor die kwaliteit van onderwys wat aan SuidAfrikaanse kinders gebied word in die verskillende grade en fases van formele skoolonderrig. Soos die hersiening van beleid en leerplanne, en die fokus op implementering, deur middel van kurrikulêre voorsiening en ondersteuning aan onderwysers, bly die verwesentliking in terme van leerders se prestasie teleurstellend swak. Results from the prePIRLS 2011 study are used as evidence of curricular attainment that has taken place at Grade 4 level across a spectrum of 11 languages in South Africa. Die swak prestasie van Suid-Afrikaanse leerders in leesgeletterdheid is reeds in 2006 bewys deur die resultate van die Progress in Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS). PIRLS word in vyfjaarlikse siklusse uitgevoer en dien as ’n internasionaal vergelykende studie in leesgeletterdheid

Open Access

Verworwe kurrikulum

Mededingende belange