Breed and crossbreeding effects on growth, fitness and reproduction of commercial sheep in South Africa

Abstract

The study aimed to assess additive breed effects for growth (birth, weaning and ewe adult weight), fitness (lamb survival and tick count under natural challenge) and ewe reproduction traits per ewe mated in Dorpers, the most common meat breed in South Africa (SA), and the SA Mutton Merino (SAMM) a prominent dual-purpose breed in SA extensive environments. Additionally, the reciprocal crosses between the two breeds were used to estimate dam breed effects and heterosis. No conclusive additive breed differences were found for lamb weight traits, lamb survival or tick counts. There was a suggestion that lamb survival of Dorpers was higher than that of their SAMM contemporaries, but significance could not be demonstrated. Crossbred progeny outperformed the midparent value by 7.1% for weaning weight. As far as mature ewes were concerned, mating weight was affected by breed combination with the mating weights of purebred SAMM ewes as well as crossbred ewes exceeding that of purebred Dorpers. Number of lambs born per ewe lambed was independent of the genetic group. The SAMM x Dorper group outperformed the pure breeds for number of lambs weaned per ewe mated (NLW). Contrasts for additive breed and maternal heterosis were not significant for NLW, but direct heterosis amounted to 32.5%. Crossbred ewes performed better than the pure breeds for total weight of lamb weaned per ewe lambed, direct heterosis amounting to 38.4%. The other contrasts were not significant. A lack of additive effects for traits, barring ewe mating weight suggested that the breeds performed similarly under the conditions of the study. Significant heterosis effects for weaning weight as well as number and weight of lamb weaned suggest a role for crosses between Dorpers and SAMMs in commercial lamb production enterprises.