Breaking the Mold: Towards Rapid and Cost-Effective Microbial Contamination Detection in Paints and Cosmetics Using ATP-Bioluminescence

Abstract

Traditional culture-based methods, though a “gold standard” for bacterial detection in various industrial sectors, do often not fulfill today’s high requirements regarding rapidity, on-site applicability, and cost-efficiency both during operation and evaluation. Here, the feasibility of using an adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-based assay for determining microbial contaminations in paints and cosmetics was investigated and compared with standard plate count techniques and dipslides. Therefore, we initially determined the level of sensitivity and assessed the accuracy and concordance among the different methods via spiking tests using a mix of frequently abundant bacterial species to simulate microbial contamination. Bioluminescence intensity was linearly proportional to log colony counts over five orders of magnitude (R2 = 0.99), indicating a high level of sensitivity. Overall, the accuracy varied depending on the test specimen, most probably due to matrix-related quenching effects. Although the degree of conformity was consistently higher at target concentrations ≥ 105 CFU·mL−1, microbial contaminations were detectable down to 103 CFU·mL−1, thus meeting the high requirements of various industries. ATP-based results tended to be within an order of magnitude lower than the reference. However, bearing that in mind, the developed assay serves as a rapid, real-time alternative for routine quality control and hygiene monitoring.