Abstract
Abstract. We investigate the microphysics of contrail formation behind commercial aircraft by means of the particle-based LCM (Lagrangian Cloud Module) box model. We extend the original LCM to cover the basic pathway of contrail formation on soot particles being activated into liquid droplets that soon after freeze into ice crystals. In our particle-based microphysical approach, simulation particles are used to represent different particle types (soot, droplets, ice crystals) and properties (mass/radius, number). The box model is applied in two frameworks. In the classical framework, we prescribe the dilution along one average trajectory in a single box model run. In the second framework, we perform a large ensemble of box model runs using 25 000 different trajectories inside an expanding exhaust jet as simulated by the LES (large-eddy simulation) model FLUDILES. In the ensemble runs, we see a strong radial dependence of the temperature and relative humidity evolution. Droplet formation on soot particles happens first near the plume edge and a few tenths of a second later in the plume centre. Averaging over the ensemble runs, the number of formed droplets and ice crystals increases more smoothly over time than for the single box model run with the average dilution. Consistent with previous studies, contrail ice crystal number varies strongly with atmospheric parameters like temperature and relative humidity near the contrail formation threshold. Close to this threshold, the apparent ice number emission index (product of freezing fraction and soot number emission index) strongly depends on the geometric-mean dry core radius and the hygroscopicity parameter of soot particles. The freezing fraction of soot particles slightly decreases with increasing soot particle number, particularly for higher soot number emissions. This weakens the increase of the apparent ice number emission index with rising soot number emission index. Comparison with box model results of a recent contrail formation study by Lewellen (2020) (using similar microphysics) shows a later onset of our contrail formation due to a weaker prescribed plume dilution. If we use the same dilution data, our evolution and Lewellen's evolution in contrail ice nucleation show an excellent agreement cross-verifying both microphysics implementations. This means that differences in contrail properties mainly result from different representations of the plume mixing and not from the microphysical modelling. Using an ensemble mean framework instead of a single trajectory does not necessarily lead to an improved scientific outcome. Contrail ice crystal numbers tend to be overestimated since the interaction between the different trajectories is not considered. The presented aerosol and microphysics scheme describing contrail formation is of intermediate complexity and thus suited to be incorporated in an LES model for 3D contrail formation studies explicitly simulating the jet expansion. Our box model results will help interpret the upcoming, more complex 3D results.
Highlights
Aviation contributes to around 5 % of the anthropogenic climate impact (Lee et al, 2021), where contrail cirrus is the largest known contributor in terms of radiative forcing (e.g. Boucher et al, 2013; Bock and Burkhardt, 2016)
This section gives a short overview of the basic Lagrangian Cloud Module (LCM) (Sect. 2.1), which has been extensively used for simulations of natural cirrus as well as young and aged contrails in the recent past
We find a perfect agreement between both models with an only some hundredth of seconds earlier increase in AEIice for the LCM. (Note that the dashed and dotted green lines are mostly covered by the solid line)
Summary
Aviation contributes to around 5 % of the anthropogenic climate impact (Lee et al, 2021), where contrail cirrus is the largest known contributor in terms of radiative forcing (e.g. Boucher et al, 2013; Bock and Burkhardt, 2016). Due to projections of large increases in air traffic, this contribution is expected to increase significantly (Bock and Burkhardt, 2019). The number of nucleated contrail ice crystals has a large impact on contrail cirrus properties and their life cycle The formation of contrails depends on complex (thermo)dynamic, microphysical and chemical processes in the exhaust plume, leading to a large variability in initial ice crystal numbers. Measurements and observations implicate that contrails form once the plume mixture between the exhaust and ambient air reaches or surpasses water saturation. This condition is mathematically cast in form of the Schmidt–Appleman (SA) criterion, a relation derived purely from the thermodynamics of the mixing process (Schumann, 1996)
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Free) 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a call
