Bowen ratio, eddy correlation, and portable chamber measurements of sensible and latent heat flux over irrigated spring wheat

Abstract

Measurements of the latent ( LE) and sensible ( H) heat flux density in the atmospheric boundary layer of irrigated crops have applications for understanding processes in agriculture and meteorology and for water management. The objective of this research was to compare measured Bowen ratios and calculated LE and H from four Bowen ratio systems (BR1–BR4) of different design with each other and with fluxes measured by three sets of eddy correlation instrumentation ( H and LE) and a portable chamber ( LE). Measurements were made on 9 and 10 April 1989 in an irrigated wheat field at the Maricopa Agricultural Center near Maricopa, Arizona. The Bowen ratio system designs varied in terms of temperature and humidity sensors and measurement arm movement. Bowen ratios were lower (more negative) on 9 April for all of the systems. The range of the four Bowen ratios was greatest in the early morning and late afternoon ( ±0.1) and least around noon ( +0.02). Measured net radiation and soil heat flux density were constant in the Bowen ratio LE calculations. The range of daytime LE from the four systems on 9 April and from three on 10 April was 11% and 1% of the mean LE, respectively. The three eddy correlation H measurements were essentially equal to each other. The average eddy correlation H was 82% and 69% of Bowen ratio H on 9 and 10 April, respectively whilst the eddy correlation LE was 77% and 67% of Bowen ratio LE on the two days. On 9 and 10 April, portable chamber LE was greater than Bowen ratio LE during periods of southerly winds owing to the effect of advected energy to the southern field edge where chamber measurements were made. On 10 April, portable chamber LE was 125% of Bowen ratio LE. This study has shown that: (1) Bowen ratios from instrumentation of different designs were similar; (2) eddy correlation H from three systems were similar to each other and were slightly less than Bowen ratio H; (3) eddy correlation LE was consistently and significantly less than Bowen ratio LE; (4) measurements of portable chamber LE on the edge of a field were affected by surrounding conditions.