Bone marrow transplantation or chemotherapy as post-remission treatment of adult acute myelogenous leukemia

Abstract

We compared three consolidation regimens in patients with acute myelogenous leukemia in first remission. Thirty-four patients received only intensive consolidation chemotherapy (SIC); 28 patients were scheduled to undergo an autologous bone marrow transplant (auto-BMT) and 44 patients an allogeneic BMT (allo-BMT). Twenty-seven of them were referred in first remission for allo-BMT. Nineteen patients achieved a complete remission after salvage treatment. All other patients obtained a remission after one or two courses of a standard combination of cytosine arabinoside and daunorubicin. Except for the patients who were referred in remission, all patients received intermediate dose cytosine arabinoside and amsacrine as a first consolidation treatment. The median ages of the three groups were 48 (SIC), 39 (auto-BMT) and 33 years (allo-BMT). Two patients relapsed before auto-BMT and 1 before allo-BMT. The median interval from the date of complete remission to the auto- or allo-BMT was 3 months. In total, 80% of the patients of the SIC group relapsed, compared to 50% of the patients belonging to the auto-BMT group and 35% of the 44 patients who were scheduled to receive an allo-BMT. The overall median disease-free survival was 14 months, 30% of the patients being alive and disease-free at 3 years. The disease-free survival rate at three years was 25% for the SIC group, 30% for the allo-BMT group and 40% for the ABMT group (P = 0.45). Our study shows no benefit for bone marrow transplantation over intensive consolidation treatment. However, large randomized trials are required to define the real value of these treatment modalities.