Bonding Quandary in the [Cu3S2]3+Core: Insights from the Analysis of Domain Averaged Fermi Holes and the Local Spin

Abstract

The electronic structure of the trinuclear symmetric complex [(tmedaCu)3S2 ](3+), whose Cu3S2 core represents a model of the active site of metalloenzymes involved in biological processes, has been in recent years the subject of vigorous debate. The complex exists as an open-shell triplet, and discussions concerned the question whether there is a direct S-S bond in the [Cu3S2](3+) core, whose answer is closely related to the problem of the formal oxidation state of Cu atoms. In order to contribute to the elucidation of the serious differences in the conclusions of earlier studies, we report in this study the detailed comprehensive analysis of the electronic structure of the [Cu3S2](3+) core using the methodologies that are specifically designed to address three particular aspects of the bonding in the core of the above complex, namely, the presence and/or absence of direct S-S bond, the existence and the nature of spin-spin interactions among the atoms in the core, and the formal oxidation state of Cu atoms in the core. Using such a combined approach, it was possible to conclude that the picture of bonding consistently indicates the existence of a weak direct two-center-three-electron (2c-3e) S-S bond, but at the same time, the observed lack of any significant local spin in the core of the complex is at odds with the suggested existence of antiferromagnetic coupling among the Cu and S atoms, so that the peculiarities of the bonding in the complex seem to be due to extensive delocalization of the unpaired spin in the [Cu3S2](3+) core. Finally, a scrutiny of the effective atomic hybrids and their occupations points to a predominant formal Cu(II) oxidation state, with a weak contribution of partial Cu(I) character induced mainly by the partial flow of electrons from S to Cu atoms and high delocalization of the unpaired spin in the [Cu3S2](3+) core.