Bond failure rates for V-loop vs straight wire lingual retainers

Abstract

The V-loop bonded lingual retainer is an innovative design that allows the patient to floss with ease, a significant advantage over the conventional straight wire design for interproximal plaque control. The aim of this retrospective study was to compare the efficacy of straight wire and V-loop fixed retainers with respect to detachment rate when used to stabilize maxillary or mandibular anterior teeth after orthodontic treatment. Fixed, customized retainers were placed in 300 patients and followed for 6 months. The conventional retainer system was a .0175-in stainless steel multi-stranded wire placed as a straight, bonded lingual retainer. The newer system was a .016-in stainless steel black Australian wire placed in a V-loop design. The detachment rates were 14.3% for the V-loop design and 12.4% for the straight wire retainer. The difference was not statistically significant. The V-loop retainer system addresses cleanability and physiologic adaptability, both critical for the clinical success of bonded lingual retainers used for long-term retention. The interdental wire span of the V-loop design allows easier access for flossing and sufficient flexibility for independent tooth movement in the periodontal space. Patient acceptance of the V-loop bonded lingual retainer was excellent, and most patients in this study found the retainer comfortable and easy to floss.