Bold–shy continuum does not account for egg rejection behaviour in the Japanese tit

Abstract

Abstract In response to brood parasitism, which significantly reduces the reproductive success of avian hosts, hosts have evolved the ability to recognize and reject parasitic eggs. Many studies have revealed the factors influencing egg recognition and egg rejection. Recent work has demonstrated that host personality along the bold–shy continuum can influence egg rejection behaviour. In addition, the egg rejection behaviour of hosts differs among populations, suggesting that individuals with different personalities might evolve various adaptive behaviours under different parasitic pressures, but there have been few relevant experiments to test this. In the present study, two populations of the Japanese tit, Parus minor, distributed in China were used to examine whether there were differences in egg rejection behaviour of individuals with different personalities. The results showed that egg rejection rates of bold individuals (which remained in the nest box when encountering human invaders) and shy individuals (which immediately flew away from the nest box when encountering human invaders) were similar in both populations of the Japanese tit, and there were also no significant differences in egg rejection rates between individuals of the same personality in the two populations. This study suggests that host personality along the bold–shy continuum does not account for egg rejection behaviour in Japanese tits. This might be attributable either to other factors that affect egg rejection behaviour counteracting the effect of personality or to the presence of multiple personality traits that act together in the Japanese tits, counteracting the effect of a single personality trait.