Body size, not maladaptive gene flow, explains death-feigning behaviour in Timema cristinae stick insects

Abstract

Eco-evolutionary feedback loops, where rapid evolution influences the ecology of an organism and subsequently alters the evolutionary trajectory of the population, are intriguing possibilities, but evidence for or against them is scarce. Timema cristinae stick insects express variation within and among populations in the expression of death-feigning behaviour, but the causes of variation in this species is not known. Here, I test the hypothesis that variation in death feigning across populations stems from an eco-evolutionary feedback loop, whereby gene flow causes poor camouflage, which increases the strength of bird predation, and ultimately drives the evolution of increased death-feigning. By conducting behavioural trials on eight T. cristinae populations that differ in the degree of maladaptive gene flow incurred, I falsify the eco-evolutionary feedback hypothesis for the evolution of death-feigning. Instead, I show that smaller individuals are more likely to feign death than larger individuals. By rearing individuals in the lab, I offer suggestive evidence that the body size effect is explained by the age of wild-caught individuals: younger individuals feign death more than older individuals. These findings add an example to the literature where no eco-evolutionary feedback exists in a system for which other similar feedbacks have been found, and provide evidence that death-feigning behaviour depends on body size.