Biomechanical analysis of stability of joint depression calcaneal fractures: Fixation with locking compression plate alone compared with addition of supplemental oblique screw

Abstract

PurposeThe standard treatment of calcaneus fractures is a lateral plate and screw construct. Patients at our institution have been treated with a lateral locking plate combined with one retrograde screw inserted in the oblique plane to allow immediate weight bearing. The purpose of this study was to determine whether addition of a oblique screw to a lateral plate construct increases stability. MethodsA Sanders 2B fracture (AO/OTA 83-C2) was created in 8 pairs (16 total specimens) of cadaveric feet. All were repaired using a lateral locking plate/screws construct. One specimen in each pair was chosen randomly to receive an additional oblique screw. The specimens were tested with cyclic load of up to 800 N. Movement at the fracture sites and subsidence of the talus were tracked with a three-dimensional video analysis system. ResultsTalar subsidence was not significantly affected by the presence of the additional oblique screw (p = 0.22). The sustentaculum fragment in the case of the screw repair moved 0.39 mm while the same fragment without the additional screw repair displaced 0.12 mm (p < 0.01). Two repairs with and one repair without the additional screw failed during longer-term cyclic loading. ConclusionThe two repair types were not statistically different in regards to talar subsidence. While statistical significance resulted in the comparison of sustentaculum fragment movement, the amount of movement did not reach a level of clinical relevance. This study demonstrated immediate stability and durability of the additional screw construct with high volume weight bearing loads.