Biomechanical analysis of plating techniques for unstable lateral clavicle fractures with coracoclavicular ligament disruption (Neer typeIIB).

Abstract

Neer type IIB lateral clavicle fractures are inherently unstable fractures with associated disruption of the coracoclavicular (CC) ligaments. Because of the high rate of nonunion and malunion, surgical fixation is recommended; however, no consensus has been reached regarding the optimal fixation method. A newplating technique using a superior lateral locking plate with anteroposterior (AP) locking screws, resulting in orthogonal fixation in the lateral fragment, has been designed to enhance stability and reduce implant failure. The purpose of this study was to biomechanically compare 3 different clavicle plating constructs within a fresh frozen human cadaveric shoulder model. Twenty-four fresh frozen cadaveric shoulders were randomized into 3 groups (n=8 specimens): group 1, lateral locking plate only (Medartis Aptus Superior Lateral Plate); group 2, lateral locking plate with CC stabilization (No. 2 FiberWire); and group 3, lateral locking plate with 2 AP locking screws stabilizing the lateral fragment. All specimens were subject to cyclic loading of 70 N for 500 cycles. Data were analyzed for gap formation after cyclic loading, construct stiffness, and ultimate load to failure, defined by a marked decrease in the load displacement curve. After 500 cycles, there was no statistically significant difference between the 3 groups in gap formation (P=.179). No specimen (0/24) failed during cyclic loading. Ultimate load to failure was significantly higher in group 3 compared to group 1 (286 N vs. 167 N; P=.022), but not to group 2 (286 N vs. 246 N; P=.604). There were no statistically significant differences in stiffness (group 1: 504 N/mm; group 2: 564 N/mm; group 3: 512 N/mm; P=.712). Peri-implant fracture was the primary mode of failure for all 3 groups, with group 3 demonstrating the lowest rate of peri-implant fractures (group 1: 6/8; group 2: 7/8; group 3: 4/8; P=.243). Biomechanical evaluation of the clavicle plating techniques showed effective fixation across all specimens at 500 cycles. The lateral locking plate with orthogonal AP locking screw fixation in the lateral fragment demonstrated the greatest ultimate failure load, followed by the lateral locking plate with CC stabilization. This new plating technique showed compatible stiffness and gap formation when compared to conventional lateral locking plates as well as plates with CC fixation. The use of orthogonal screw fixation in the distal fragment may negate against the need for CC stabilization in these types of fractures, thus minimizing surgical dissection around the coracoid and potential complications.