Biomechanical analysis of different internal fixation methods for special Maisonneuve fracture of the ankle joint based on finite element analysis

Abstract

ObjectiveThe objective of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical properties of different internal fixation methods for Maisonneuve fractures under physiological loading conditions. MethodsFinite element analysis was used to numerically analyze various fixation methods. The study focused on high fibular fractures and included six groups of internal fixation: high fibular fracture without fixation + distal tibiofibular elastic fixation (group A), high fibular fracture without fixation + distal tibiofibular strong fixation (group B), high fibular fracture with 7-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular elastic fixation (group C), high fibular fracture with 7-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular strong fixation (group D), high fibular fracture with 5-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular elastic fixation (group E), and high fibular fracture with 5-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular strong fixation (group F). The finite element method was employed to simulate and analyze the different internal fixation models for the six groups, generating overall structural displacement and Von Mises stress distribution maps during slow walking and external rotation motions. ResultsGroup A demonstrated the best ankle stability under slow walking and external rotation, with reduced tibial and fibular stress after fibular fracture fixation. Group D had the least displacement and most stability, while group A had the largest displacement and least stability. Overall, high fibular fracture fixation improved ankle stability. In slow walking, groups D and A had the least and greatest interosseous membrane stress. Comparing 5-hole plate (E/F) and 7-hole plate (C/D) fixation, no significant differences were found in ankle strength or displacement under slow walking or external rotation. ConclusionCombining internal fixation for high fibular fractures with elastic fixation of the lower tibia and fibula is optimal for orthopedic treatment. It yields superior outcomes compared to no fibular fracture fixation or strong fixation of the lower tibia and fibula, especially during slow walking and external rotation. To minimize nerve damage, a smaller plate is recommended. This study strongly advocates for the clinical use of 5-hole plate internal fixation for high fibular fractures with elastic fixation of the lower tibia and fibula (group E).