Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning in a species-poor guild: a test using tropical stream detritivores

Abstract

The relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem functioning (B–EF) was investigated by examining top-down effects of aquatic detritivore diversity on the functional process of leaf-litter breakdown. This study was undertaken in tropical Hong Kong where the stream detritivore guild is depauperate and loss of one or a few species might have strong effects on processes. Effects of detritivore richness and composition were investigated by comparing feeding rates of three species of detritivores with their two- and three-species mixtures in laboratory trials. The detritivores were a caddisfly larva (Anisocentropus maculatus: Calamoceratidae), a snail (Brotia hainanensis: Pachychilidae) and a shrimp (Caridina cantonensis: Atyidae). Liquidambar formosana (Hamamelidaceae) litter was provided as food. All three detritivore species had positive non-additive effects on litter processing. Per capita and mass-specific feeding rates of each species were faster in mixtures than when they were alone, although the non-additive effects of shrimps and snails were larger than those attributable to caddisflies, and thus, litter processing was strongly influenced by the composition of detritivore mixtures. The compositional effect appears to be evidence of facilitation indicating a lack of functional redundancy amongst these detritivores, probably due to their evolutionary distinctness, implying that extinction consequences in this species-poor guild will depend on the identity of the species lost.