Biochar slows gross nitrification and gasses N emission via lower autotrophic nitrification in paddy soils

Abstract

Laboratory incubation experiments using 15N stable isotope labeling and acetylene suppression techniques were conducted to compare the autotrophic nitrification and heterotrophic nitrification rates with the addition of swine manure (SW) and swine-manure-derived biochar (SWB) in two paddy soils. SW and SWB were applied at four N-based amendment levels, namely control (0 mg N kg−1), low (1.1 mg N kg−1), medium (2.2 mg N kg−1), and high (4.4 mg N kg−1). Twenty-five milliliters of C2H2 gas were injected into each storage bottle to inhibit autotrophic nitrification in soil. At the end of the preincubation period, 160 mg kg−1 15N-glycine were added to each storage bottle to stimulate heterotrophic nitrification in soil. Results showed that SW increased the NH4+-N content by 3.5 to 17.5 mg kg−1 in both soils, while SWB decreased it by 0.1 to 4.7 mg kg−1 compared to control group, regardless of whether autotrophic nitrification was inhibited. Both SW and SWB enhanced NO3−-N accumulation in the two soils compared to control group when autotrophic nitrification was not inhibited; however, NO3−-N concentration in the soil with SWB was up to 24% lower than that with the same level of SW addition. NH3 volatilization rates were elevated at all the SW and SWB amendment levels, although only SW led to higher N2O emission rates. Compared with SW, high level of SWB significantly decreased N2O emissions by 78 to 84% in the loam and clay loam soils. The increase in NH3 volatilization, soil NO3−-N accumulation, and autotrophic nitrification rate were greater with SW than with SWB. Higher rates of soil heterotrophic nitrification were observed in SWB-amended soils than in SW-amended soils with a high (4.4 mg N kg−1) amendment level. Our results suggest that SWB is less likely to increase NO3−-N accumulation in soil and contributes more to the lower soil autotrophic nitrification rate compared with SW. Although SWB can promote heterotrophic nitrification, it generally inhibits the autotrophic nitrification process and slows the increment pace of the gross nitrification in paddy soils.