Binding and antiresorptive properties of heterocycle-containing bisphosphonate analogs: structure-activity relationships

Abstract

To define structure-activity relationships for bisphosphonate activity, we examined the bone binding and antiresorptive properties of heterocycle-containing analogs of risedronate, a pyridylbisphosphonate, in cultures of mouse fetal bone explants. Our studies indicated that hydroxybisphosphonates with the nitrogen molecule in the pyridyl ring were very potent inhibitors of osteoclastic resorption. Changing the place of the nitrogen in the ring structure of risedronate or its methylation did not significantly alter antiresorptive potency in relation to risedronate. Extension of the R 2 chain, however, reduced efficacy. In binding experiments, we found that all heterocyclic bisphosphonates with a hydroxyl group in R 1 had comparable affinity for bone mineral and inhibited calcium incorporation into bone explants to a similar extent. The affinity of a risedronate analog without R 1 was markedly reduced. We also examined the properties of a risedronate analog (NE-10790) belonging to the group of phosphonocarboxylates in which one of the phosphonate groups is substituted by a carboxyl group. NE-10790 had strongly reduced binding affinity, but still retained some antiresorptive activity. Interestingly, the continuous presence of NE-10790 in cultures of fetal mouse metacarpal bones increased its antiresorptive efficacy by about 40-fold compared with 24 h preincubation, whereas, under the same conditions, the potency of high-affinity hydroxybisphosphonates did not change or only slightly increased. This may be explained by the differences in pharmacokinetic behavior between compounds of high and of low affinity for bone mineral. These data show that, as with alkylbisphosphonates, heterocycle-containing bisphosphonates with a nitrogen functionality in the R 2 chain are potent antiresorptive agents and a hydroxyl substitution in the R 1 chain confers high affinity for bone mineral, probably due to tridentate configuration. The group of phosphonocarboxylates, with strongly reduced bone affinity, provides an interesting therapeutic option.