Bimodality and Gaps on Globular Cluster Horizontal Branches. II. The Cases of NGC 6229, NGC 1851, and NGC 2808

Abstract

The outer halo globular cluster NGC 6229 has a peculiar horizontal-branch (HB) morphology, with clear indications of a bimodal HB and a gap on the blue HB. In this paper, we present extensive synthetic HB simulations to determine whether peculiar distributions in the underlying physical parameters are needed to explain the observed HB morphology. We find that a unimodal mass distribution along the HB can satisfactorily account for the observed HB bimodality, provided the mass dispersion is substantially larger than usually inferred for the Galactic globular clusters. In this case, NGC 6229 should have a well-populated, extended blue tail. A truly bimodal distribution in HB masses can also satisfactorily account for the observed HB morphology, although in this case the existence of an extended blue tail is not necessarily implied. The other two well-known bimodal-HB clusters, NGC 1851 and NGC 2808, are briefly analyzed. While the HB morphology of NGC 1851 can also be reproduced with a unimodal mass distribution assuming a large mass dispersion, the same is not true of NGC 2808, for which a bimodal, and possibly multimodal, mass distribution seems definitely required. The problem of gaps on the blue HB is also discussed. Applying the standard Hawarden and Newell χ2 test, we find that the NGC 6229 gap is significant at the 99.7% level. However, in a set of 1000 simulations, blue-HB gaps comparable to the observed one are present in ~6%-9% of all cases. We employ a new and simple formalism, based on the binomial distribution, to explain the origin of this discrepancy, and conclude that Hawarden's method, in general, substantially overestimates the statistical significance of gaps.