Abstract

This article showcases a detailed description of the first stage of research on the discourse of Ukrainian opinion leaders on Facebook conducted by a team of researchers representing MGIMO University, Lomonosov Moscow State University, and Institute of Economy at the Russian Academy of Sciences. Convinced that it is Facebook that serves as the primary means of communication of politicians with the population in Ukraine, the team built a data base consisting of posts written over a 10-month period by 176 profiles belonging to the representatives of Ukrainian elites, and applied machine data analysis. The research question was the following: What strategies on the conflict in Donbas are verbalized by the Ukrainian elites? The author faced three challenges and limitations of machine data processing and analysis:unsuccessful operationalization of terms; functional limitations of the Semantic Archive Platform, of which the author turned out to have unreasonably high expectations; lack of understanding of peculiarities of Big Data analysis. Nevertheless, it was the failure of this pilot research that helped raise crucial questions for further research, primarily on the criteria for shaping a data base and on formulating of the research questions for software. This experience turned to be essential for second and third stages of the research project that were completed a year and half after the project was launched. Hence the necessity to make public all the considerations on this research.

Highlights

  • This article showcases a detailed description of the first stage of research on the discourse of Ukrainian opinion leaders on Facebook conducted by a team of researchers representing MGIMO University, Lomonosov Moscow State University, and Institute of Economy at the Russian Academy of Sciences

  • Convinced that it is Facebook that serves as the primary means of communication of politicians with the population in Ukraine, the team built a data base consisting of posts written over a 10-month period by 176 profiles belonging to the representatives of Ukrainian elites, and applied machine data analysis

  • The research question was the following: What strategies on the conflict in Donbas are verbalized by the Ukrainian elites? The author faced three challenges and limitations of machine data processing and analysis: No 2 (24) 2018 unsuccessful operationalization of terms; functional limitations of the Semantic Archive Platform, of which the author turned out to have unreasonably high expectations; lack of understanding of peculiarities of Big Data analysis

Read more

Summary

РАССУЖДЕНИЕ О МЕТОДАХ

Big Data в исследовании соцсетей: опыт неудачного машинного анализа украинского Facebook*. Однако именно неудачный опыт пилотажного исследования позволил поставить принципиально важные вопросы для дальнейшей работы – прежде в всего, о критериях базы данных и об исследовательских вопросах, которые автор адресует машине. Зор литературы по теме, после этого указано на сложности проведения операционализации для постановки технического задания программистам, затем дается ответ на вопрос: почему для исследования мнения украинских элит был выбран именно Facebook, рассказано о формировании списка аккаунтов и работе с поисковым запросом. Так ли уж стоит восхвалять украинский сегмент Facebook в качестве объекта для репрезентативного исследования, когда туда не пишут бизнесмен Игорь Коломойский и директор президентского НИСИ Владимир Горбулин? При всем обаянии Big Data воображать, что мы можем исследовать всё, просто глупо. Которая, будучи описанной многостраничным программным кодом в соответствии с нашими пожеланиями и проведённой операционализацией, в один миг (клик!) выдаст ответ на поисковый запрос настолько точный, что именно то, что мы искали, будет в базе данных, а то, что нам принципиально не нужно, туда не попадет

Почему украинский Facebook?
Формирование списка аккаунтов и работа с поисковым запросом
Объект поиска
Поисковый запрос
Провал в определении стратегий
Стратегии Завоевание Заморозка Вовлечение Отгораживание
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.