Beyond the ‘Habits’ of ‘Punishing, Criticising and Nagging’: Fostering Respectful and Socially Just Student Relations Using Critical Pedagogies

Abstract

This chapter presents a pedagogical approach to fostering respectful and inclusive student relations. Rather than a narrow focus on managing or controlling students, this approach enables a broad and located view of student behaviour that seeks to develop and extend students’ understandings of themselves and others. A key premise here is that many ‘misbehaviours’ in classrooms are associated with issues of identity and power and, in particular, the ways in which conventional classrooms and teacher–student relations tend to render students with little power or agency. Acting out or against this positioning as a means of asserting a sense of power or legitimacy is often at the root of disruptive or harmful behaviours. Thus, it is contended here that beginning to transform such behaviours necessitates an environment where students are accorded a voice and where they are supported to reflect critically on issues of power and identity in connected and meaningful ways. The chapter explores these issues with reference to the practices of ‘Rachel’, the deputy principal of a working-class secondary school in Queensland. Her practice is theorised drawing on the Productive Pedagogies model – a model designed as a meta-language for teachers to reflect on ways that they can integrate social justice issues within, rather than separate to, the pedagogical process. Given that boys continue to perpetuate the lion’s share of disciplinary transgressions in schools, the focus in this chapter is on issues of masculinity.