Beyond Energies: Geometries of Nonbonded Molecular Complexes as Metrics for Assessing Electronic Structure Approaches.

Abstract

Electronic structure approaches for calculating intermolecular interactions have traditionally been benchmarked almost exclusively on the basis of energy-centric metrics. Herein, we explore the idea of utilizing a metric related to geometry. On a diverse series of noncovalently interacting systems of different sizes, from the water dimer to the coronene dimer, we evaluate a variety of electronic structure approximations with respect to their abilities to reproduce coupled-cluster-level geometries. Specifically, we examine Hartree-Fock, second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2), attenuated MP2, scaled MP2, and a number of density functionals, many of which include empirical or nonempirical van der Waals dispersion corrections. We find a number of trends that transcend system size and interaction type. For instance, functionals incorporating VV10 nonlocal correlation tend to yield highly accurate geometries; ωB97X-V and B97M-V, in particular, stand out. We establish that intermolecular distance, as measured by, e.g., the center-of-mass separation of two molecules, is the geometric parameter that deviates most profoundly among the various methods. This property of the equilibrium intermolecular separation, coupled with its accessibility via a small series of well-defined single-point calculations, makes it an ideal metric for the development and evaluation of electronic structure methods.