Better Resolution for Cytochrome b than Cytochrome c Oxidase Subunit I to Identify Schizothorax Species (Teleostei: Cyprinidae) from the Tibetan Plateau and Its Adjacent Area.

Abstract

The genus Schizothorax is one of the most diverse groups of schizothoracine fish. Many species within this genus possess highly similar morphological characters and are very difficult to be identified accurately only based on morphology. The present study aims to test the effectiveness of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene and cytochrome b (Cytb) gene for discriminating the Schizothorax fish. A total of 185 individuals of 11 species for COI gene and 264 individuals of 23 species for Cytb gene were used for analyzing, respectively. According to the genetic distances, only one species based on COI gene and five species based on Cytb gene had "barcoding gaps," respectively. The tree-based analysis displayed that four species based on COI gene and six species based on Cytb gene clustered monophyletic group with strong support, respectively. The optimal threshold value of Schizothorax is 0.005 based on COI gene and 0.008 based on Cytb gene. The results of genetic similarity tests performed through online BLAST showed that 108 of 185 similarity searches succeeded in identifying conspecific sequences based on COI gene and 199 of 264 succeeded in identifying conspecific sequences based on Cytb gene. Considering greater interspecific genetic distance in Kimura 2-parameter (K2P) analysis and many clades with higher supporting values in tree-based analysis, we suggest that Cytb gene has better resolution in discrimination of Schizothorax species than COI gene. However, there are still many confused clustering relationships based on molecular data currently available. Incomplete lineage sorting, the existence of possible cryptic species and problematic morphological identification, etc. might have greatly weakened the resolution of Cytb gene in discrimination of Schizothorax species.