Behavior of nursery-box-applied fipronil and its sulfone metabolite in rice paddy fields

Abstract

The granular insecticide fipronil has been widely applied in rice nursery boxes, both before transplanting (BT) and during at-sowing (AS) treatments to control insect pests at the early stages of rice cultivation in Japan. Although a potential effect of fipronil on paddy ecosystems and downstream aquatic environments has been observed, the environmental effect of this substance in paddy fields remains unsought. Here we investigate the environmental behavior of nursery-box-applied granular fipronil and its sulfone metabolite in paddy water and paddy soils during BT and AS treatments performed in a paddy field in Japan. Although the fipronil concentrations in the paddy water in the AS treatment were significantly lower than those measured in the BT treatment, no significant differences were observed in the paddy soil between the two treatments. Fipronil was mainly found in the 0- to 5-cm surface soil layer of the rice-root zone, where its concentrations were approximately ten times higher than those in the soil of the inter-row zone. The insecticide concentration in the 0- to 1-cm layer of the inter-row zone in the surface soil was approximately 2.5 times higher than that in the 0- to 5-cm layer. The maximum concentrations of fipronil in the 0- to 1-cm surface soil layer ranged from 65.8 to 92.1μg/kg on the first day after rice transplanting (DAT), and the corresponding values in the paddy water ranged from 0.9 to 2.5μg/L. The dissipation of fipronil from the paddy water and paddy soil was described by first-order kinetics. The compound's half-life (DT50) was 0.9–3.1 days in paddy water and 12.3–26.4 days in paddy soil. Compared to the BT treatment, the AS treatment may pose a smaller risk to the paddy water and the adjacent environment. Fipronil sulfone was found in every water and soil sample, with the maximum concentrations ranging from 0.4 to 0.9μg/L in the paddy water and from 9.7 to 59.2μg/kg in the paddy soil on the third DAT. These values gradually decreased over time. Ecotoxicological risk assessments of fipronil products in rice paddies should not only consider the toxicity of fipronil itself but also that of fipronil sulfone because of its relatively high concentrations in paddy water and paddy soil