Basis set effects on Cu(I) coordination in Cu-ZSM-5: a computational study

Abstract

DFT calculations on the coordination of Cu+ to the framework oxygen atoms of Al-substituted ZSM-5 were performed by using combinations of different basis sets in order to investigate the dependence of the results on the adopted computational level. With low-end basis sets, a large basis set superposition error (BSSE) favors the coordination of Cu+ to three to four oxygen atoms of the framework, only two of which belong to the AlO4 tetrahedron corresponding to the investigated T-site. More extended basis sets considerably lower the BSSE and favor the coordination of Cu+ to only two oxygen atoms of the AlO4 tetrahedron. Upon interaction with NO, the Cu+ ion is always coordinated by two oxygen atoms of the AlO4 tetrahedron, independently of the basis set adopted and of the coordination number before NO adsorption. The shift from three- to twofold coordination caused by the Cu+–NO interaction requires a deformation energy that lowers the final adsorption energy. Such an effect is relevant with low-end basis sets, whereas it is substantially absent with more extended basis sets, which favor the twofold coordination of Cu+ even before NO adsorption. As a result, high-end basis sets increase the NO interaction energy with respect to that calculated by low-end basis sets, in agreement with experiments and suggesting a possible re-interpretation of the catalytic properties of the investigated sites. Provided suitable scale factors are employed, the N–O stretching frequencies of adsorbed nitrogen oxide calculated by sufficiently extended basis sets turned out in fair agreement with experimental findings.