Basedow disease. From subtotal to total thyroidectomy

Abstract

Surgical treatment of Graves' disease is based on modern pathophysiolic understanding and adequate surgical tactic and technique. This is an audit from one institution about 81 consecutive, prospectively documented patients, undergoing subtotal (remnant < 6 g) or total thyroidectomy, by the technique of capsular dissection. Patients were female in 89%, aged 11-79 (median 35) years. They constitute 9% of all thyroid operations, i.e. 47% of those performed for hyperthyroidism. Indications were persistence and recurrence of disease, orbitopathy, large goiter, nodule formation, refusal of radioiodine, preconception control. Preoperative treatment was thyrostatic (97%), iodine (87%), propranolol (50%). During the study period use of total thyroidectomy increased from 0% to 87% (p < 0.0001), and the remnant size decreased from median 3.5 g to 0 g (p < 0.0001). Goiter weight was 20-255 g, median 70.28 (23%) patients had concomitant colloid or adenomatous nodules, 5 (6%) had an incidental microcarcinoma, and 3 (4%) had a clinical papillary or follicular carcinoma, 1 patient had a parathyroid adenoma. Mortality was 0; surgical morbidity was early postoperative haemorrhage (n = 2 (2.5%)), permanent nerve palsy (1 patient with recurrence after previous resection (1.2%; 0.6% of nerves at risk)); no case of permanent hypoparathyroidism occurred. Functional results: In 6 patients (8%; 15% of those with subtotal resection) recurrent hyperthyroidism developed, 1 month to 8 years postoperatively, necessitating reablative treatment (surgical in 2 instances). 1 further patient developed preclinical hyperthyroidism 11 years postoperatively. Postoperative thyroxine substitution was found to be inadequate in 16/73 (20%) patients, as demonstrated by suppressed or elevated TSH values. Recurrence-free survival at 10 years was 100% in patients with a remnant measuring < 3 g, vs. 55.8% in those with a remnant size > or = 3-6 g (p = 0.002). Ophthalmopathy improved in 33/47 (70%) and deteriorated in 5 (10%) patients postoperatively, independently of the procedure (total or subtotal). Extensive or total thyroidectomy is necessary for late recurrence-free survival.--Variation of the spontaneous remnant function may occur and contribute to inadequate substitution.--(Near) total thyroidectomy has a low morbidity and is considered the treatment of choice, also with the theoretical advantage of complete autoantigene removal.--Surgical progress is based on capsular dissection with fine preparatory operative technique.